Why I Left the Vineyard Church

Why I Left the Vineyard Church: A Personal Journey of Growth and Discovery


Leaving a church is never an easy decision. It involves questioning long-held beliefs, navigating relationships, and often comes with a sense of loss and uncertainty. In this article, I will share my personal experience of why I left the Vineyard Church, a popular evangelical Christian denomination known for its contemporary worship style and emphasis on the Holy Spirit’s manifestations. Through my journey, I discovered a need for a more inclusive and progressive spiritual community that aligned with my evolving beliefs and values.

Background on the Vineyard Church

The Vineyard Church was founded in the early 1980s by John Wimber and was built upon the belief in the active presence and power of the Holy Spirit. The movement quickly gained popularity for its contemporary worship music and for emphasizing the spiritual gifts of healing, prophecy, and speaking in tongues. The Vineyard Church became known for its energetic worship services and its focus on practical Christianity, serving the poor and marginalized, and reaching out to the lost.

My Initial Attraction to the Vineyard

As a young adult searching for deeper meaning and purpose, I was drawn to the Vineyard Church. The vibrant worship, engaging sermons, and welcoming community provided a sense of belonging and fulfillment that I had longed for. The emphasis on supernatural experiences and the belief in the Holy Spirit’s active involvement in everyday life fascinated me. I was eager to explore this unique expression of faith and grow in my relationship with God.

The Changing Landscape

However, as time went on, I began to notice certain aspects of the Vineyard Church that troubled me. While the worship and community were uplifting, I felt the teachings lacked depth and critical examination of core theological doctrines. The emphasis on supernatural encounters often overshadowed the importance of intellectual engagement and biblical literacy. Additionally, I became increasingly aware of the lack of diversity in the congregation and leadership, both in terms of race and gender. It became clear to me that the Vineyard Church was operating within a certain theological framework that limited its ability to embrace different perspectives and promote inclusivity.

The Question of Exclusivity

One aspect that caused significant internal conflict for me was the church’s stance on LGBTQ+ issues. The Vineyard Church, like many evangelical denominations, held the traditional view that homosexuality was sinful and excluded LGBTQ+ individuals from leadership and certain positions within the church. As someone who valued love, acceptance, and equality, this doctrine did not sit well with me. I struggled with the notion that God’s love could be conditional based on one’s sexual orientation. It became increasingly clear that I could not continue to be a part of a community that enforced such exclusivity.

The Need for Intellectual Stimulation

Another pivotal factor in my decision to leave the Vineyard Church was the lack of intellectual stimulation I found within the community. I had grown increasingly curious about the historical and cultural contexts of the Bible, the theological implications of different interpretations, and the intersection of faith with fields like science, philosophy, and social justice. Unfortunately, these topics were rarely addressed in a meaningful way in church sermons or Bible studies. I craved a more intellectually robust environment that encouraged critical thinking and nurtured spiritual growth.

Seeking a More Inclusive Community

Ultimately, my departure from the Vineyard Church was driven by a desire to find a more inclusive and affirming spiritual community. I longed for a place where people from all walks of life could come together in worship and service, regardless of their gender, sexual orientation, or theological beliefs. I wanted to be part of a church that actively engaged with social justice issues, worked to dismantle systems of oppression, and celebrated the inherent worth and dignity of every individual. It was essential to me that my faith aligned with my values of love, acceptance, and equality.

Finding a New Path

Leaving the Vineyard Church was not an easy process. It involved navigating difficult conversations with friends and family who often struggled to understand my decision. There were moments of doubt and uncertainty as I ventured into unfamiliar spiritual territory. However, I can say with confidence that it was a journey worth taking. In my search for a new spiritual home, I have found a progressive, inclusive community that encourages both spiritual growth and intellectual exploration. I have discovered a vibrant faith that embraces diversity, promotes social justice, and celebrates the inherent worth and dignity of all people.


Leaving any church community is a deeply personal and complex decision. In my case, leaving the Vineyard Church was driven by a desire for growth, inclusivity, and aligning my faith with my values. While I cherish the positive experiences and relationships I formed within the Vineyard, I have found a new spiritual home that better reflects my evolving beliefs and desires for community. My journey out of the Vineyard Church has ultimately led me to a place of greater authenticity, where I can fully live out my faith and strive to create a more just and compassionate world.